Debit card holds on fuel purchases are back in the news. These temporary holds of up to $175 (previously $125) are placed in a customer’s bank account when they purchase fuel, regardless of the fill-up amount. As the coverage has grown, so has the misinformation.
Let’s start by answering the most important question: who is responsible for restraint? Is it the banking and credit card industry, who has your money and writes and enforces the hundreds of pages of rules that dictate the use of credit and debit cards without much government oversight? Or is it the dealer?
The answer is obvious, but first let’s take a closer look at why sockets exist.
In most retail cases, the payment amount is known at the time of payment. At the grocery store, a customer pays after all items have been scanned and bagged. It’s the same process at most other outlets, whether you’re paying for a meal, clothing or other item, in-store or online.
But there are exceptions. Holds are placed on card purchases when the final purchase amount is unknown at the time of card authorization. One situation where this applies is at the pump.
Holds are intended to represent the largest possible fill that could occur, and due to rising gas prices, Visa and Mastercard increased holds to $175 in April 2022, which has become the standard for de facto at most petrol stations in June.
Holds are placed on credit and debit cards, but since people sometimes have low balances in their bank accounts, debit card holds can have significant ramifications.
Holds are also placed when you check into a hotel or rent a car. It is increasingly rare to find a hotel or car rental service company that accepts debit cards upon arrival as the holds can be $500 or more.
One more point of clarification. There are two charges that hit your account when you buy gasoline. One is an “authorization” charge, usually for $1. This charge is not permanent and is removed later. Its purpose is to ensure that the card used is valid. The second charge is the “hold”, which is necessary to ensure that you have money to cover the transaction.
If the banks guaranteed that the gas station would be paid, the holds would not be an issue at the pumps. But this is not the case. Visa and Mastercard say that if there is no hold on the consumer’s bank account, the retailer may not get paid. Cards are used for approximately 80% of payments at the pump, more than 30 million times a day. So rolling the dice losing 80% of sales is not a realistic option, at least for retail outlets that want to stay in business.
The amount of the hold is determined by the contract between the point of sale and its bank. The amount also represents the maximum filling. This means that you cannot pump a drop above the hold amount, whether you paid by credit or debit card. If a station sets a limit that’s too low, your pump may shut off before you’ve finished filling up, which is frustrating, especially with higher gas prices.
While online bank statements appear to have been blocked by the retailer, the retailer is only responsible for setting the amount of the hold, a decision heavily influenced by credit card rules which may subsequently refuse payments for certain transactions.
More importantly, the gas station does not hold the money; it is held by the bank. Why would a resort want your money tied up in your bank? They want you to have enough funds in your account so you can buy things.
So, who benefits from the takes, especially the long ones? The bank that holds your money.
Anyone who remembers waiting for a paper check to clear knows how it works: the longer a bank can hold your money and make it “work” for them, the better for that bank.
The retailer is not responsible for the duration of the hold; it is determined by your bank. He shouldn’t stay more than a few days, and that’s important to know. If you’re on a long trip and refuel multiple times in a day or two, you could end up with a lot of cash waiting.
Multiple holds, or even an unexpected debit hold, can trigger a cascade of overdraft fees or prevent you from making further purchases. So what can you do to avoid these situations?
The duration of a hold depends on how the card is used. PIN debit transactions are real-time transactions, and holds should be released in minutes, rather than hours or days. If there isn’t a PINpad at the pump, you can use the one inside the store at the checkout, which isn’t as convenient, but it does reduce your wait time. Meanwhile, so-called signature-based debit transactions – those where customers don’t use a PIN – are treated like a credit card transaction and have longer hold times that could take days to clear. compensated.
Holds on signature-based debit transactions, such as holds on credit cards that may affect a customer’s spending limit, may remain 48-72 hours due to slower processing times. It shouldn’t take that long, but the banks and credit card companies don’t have the incentives or the competition to push them to make the system faster.
If you are concerned, you should ask your bank what their policy is regarding the duration of debit holds. If the hold lasts more than a few minutes for PIN-based transactions, or more than a few days for signature-based debit transactions, you should contact your bank to find out why the holds are taking so long.
Unfortunately, the way the debit card system works isn’t expected to change any time soon. The banking sector that issues cards is not motivated to improve its customer service. And that only adds to the frustration we face today at the pumps.